Connect with us

BUSINESS

Lifting the Social Security Cap Crowds Out the Next Fix

Some Republicans now back lifting the Social Security payroll tax cap, a move that would still leave a third of the shortfall and crowd out later tax room.

Published

on

Workers and employers now pay Social Security tax on wages only up to $184,500, and some Republicans want that ceiling gone. Sens. Bernie Moreno of Ohio and Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts said in June they are writing a bill to tax every dollar of covered earnings, a step that used to live only on the Democratic side of the aisle.

The pitch is simple: most workers already pay on their full paycheck, so the highest earners should too. The next problem is less simple. The same wallets would then be asked to backstop Medicare and a national debt that has already cleared $40 trillion, and even a full uncap still leaves about a third of Social Security’s 75-year hole unpaid.

Republicans Now Share the Cap-Lift File

Moreno, a Republican first elected in 2024, and Warren, a Democrat, published a joint opinion piece on June 23, 2026, calling the cap a fairness problem. For 2026, employees and employers each pay 6.2 percent, 12.4 percent combined, on wages up to $184,500. That puts the most any one worker can send in at $22,878, and not a dollar more even if the salary is many times that amount.

They said they are working on legislation to remove the cap so that all covered earnings are taxed at the same rate. They cited an estimate that doing so would put about $3 trillion into the program over 10 years. They also pointed to a 2025 Bipartisan Policy Center poll in which 65 percent of Democrats and 62 percent of Republicans backed lifting the cap, including a majority of households earning more than $200,000.

The two of us are working together on legislation to remove the cap on Social Security taxes and extend the solvency of our retirement system.

Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Moreno, joint statement, June 23, 2026

Reps. Tom Cole of Oklahoma and Lloyd Smucker of Pennsylvania, both Republicans, have said in separate interviews they would consider raising payroll taxes to help fund the program. Sen. Bernie Sanders has been making the same fairness case for years, asking whether the richest Americans should pay the same Social Security tax as a fireman or a nurse.

That share-of-pay gap is the fuel. A worker who never clears the cap pays on 100 percent of wages. Someone earning $1 million pays the 12.4 percent levy on less than a fifth of pay. Advocacy groups have repeated that contrast for a decade. What changed in 2026 is that a Republican senator put his name on a bill to erase it.

The Retirement Trust Fund Runs Dry in Late 2032

The trustees who oversee the program released their 2026 report on June 9. Under their intermediate path, the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund can pay 78 percent of scheduled benefits once reserves run out in the fourth quarter of 2032. That is a 22 percent cut for retirees, spouses, children, and survivors if Congress does nothing.

THE TRUSTEES’ 2026 SNAPSHOT

  • OASI depletion: Fourth quarter of 2032, with 78 percent of benefits still payable, falling to 62 percent by 2100.
  • Combined OASDI: Third quarter of 2034 if the two funds were merged by law, with 83 percent payable, falling to 65 percent by 2100.
  • 2025 cash: Combined reserves fell $160 billion to $2.56 trillion, as $1.45 trillion of income met $1.61 trillion of outlays.
  • The long-run hole: A 75-year actuarial deficit of 4.42 percent of taxable payroll, up from 3.82 percent, and a $29.3 trillion unfunded obligation.

Disability Insurance stays solvent through 2100 on this path. Combining the two funds would take an act of Congress. About 70 million people were drawing benefits at the end of 2025, and about 185 million workers paid in.

Three changes drove the worse long-run math. The assumed fertility rate was cut from 1.90 children per woman to 1.75. Near-term and long-run immigration figures were lowered. And the tax law enacted on July 4, 2025, reduced the future revenue the trust funds get from income tax on benefits.

THE DATES THAT NOW SIT ON ONE CALENDAR

  1. June 9, 2026: Trustees project OASI reserve depletion in the fourth quarter of 2032 and Medicare Hospital Insurance depletion in the second quarter of 2033.
  2. June 23, 2026: Moreno and Warren publish their plan to uncap the payroll tax and say they are drafting a bill.
  3. June 24, 2026: Tax Foundation senior economist Alex Durante publishes estimates that a full uncap would still leave the program short of 75-year balance.
  4. September 3, 2026: The Joint Economic Committee puts total gross national debt at $40.10 trillion.

Social Security Commissioner Frank J. Bisignano said lawmakers and the agency need to work together so the trust funds stay stable for future generations. The report itself does not pick a fix.

How Much of the Gap Would Lifting the Cap Close?

The Social Security actuaries have scored a clean uncap for years. Provision E2.1 applies the full 12.4 percent rate to all earnings from 2026 on and gives no extra benefit credit above today’s taxable maximum. On the 2025 trustees’ baseline, that design closes 67 percent of the long-run shortfall and pushes combined reserve depletion from 2034 to 2059. Annual deficits resume after a few surplus years.

Give credit for the extra taxed earnings, as provision E2.2 does, and the same uncap closes 48 percent of the gap. That is the trade inside every “scrap the cap” bill: more revenue if the extra wages do not raise future checks, less revenue if they do.

SHARE OF THE 75-YEAR SHORTFALL CLOSED

Design Benefit credit above the cap Share of shortfall closed
Eliminate the taxable maximum (E2.1) No 67%
Eliminate the taxable maximum (E2.2) Yes 48%
Set the maximum at 90% of earnings No 28%
Set the maximum at 90% of earnings Yes 22%

The 90 percent rows come from Roosevelt Institute work that Tyler Bond, a senior fellow at the National Academy of Social Insurance, co-authored. Bond has said it is “almost unavoidable” that a reform package will touch the taxable maximum. Permanently setting the cap at 90 percent of earnings is the milder cousin of a full uncap, and it covers far less of the hole.

A 2024 survey for the National Academy of Social Insurance, AARP, the National Institute on Retirement Security, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce found that dropping the cap for earnings above $400,000 was the most popular choice among 2,243 adults. Raising the employee and employer rates to 7.2 percent from 6.2 percent ran close behind. The survey’s margin of error was plus or minus 2.1 percentage points.

None of those options, by itself, restores 75-year balance. The leftover third, or more if extra benefits are paid, still has to come from a higher rate, a later retirement age, slower benefit growth, or some mix of the three.

A 12.4-Point Levy on a Thin Slice of Pay

Lifting the cap is a 12.4-point tax increase on wages that now sit above $184,500. Durante called it the largest tax increase since 1982, about 0.83 percent of GDP in 2027. The Tax Foundation’s model says a full uncap would reduce long-run GDP by 1.5 percent and cost 1.8 million jobs. On paper it raises $3.2 trillion from 2027 through 2036; after people work less or shift pay into untaxed benefits, that falls to $1.5 trillion.

A narrower design that lifts the cap only far enough to cover 90 percent of wages, to about $346,000 in 2027 and then indexed, is still large. The foundation’s Option 44 cuts long-run GDP by 0.7 percent and hours worked by 891,000 full-time jobs. Applying the tax again above $400,000, the so-called donut hole, cuts GDP by 0.7 percent and hours by 843,000 jobs, and raises $819.6 billion over 10 years on a dynamic basis.

MODELED HITS FROM THREE PAYROLL-TAX DESIGNS

Design Long-run GDP Jobs (full-time equivalent)
Full uncap of the $184,500 maximum -1.5% 1.8 million
Cap at 90% of wages (~$346,000 in 2027) -0.7% 891,000
Tax earnings above $400,000 (donut hole) -0.7% 843,000

William McBride, the Tax Foundation’s chief economist, said the country has not seen a levy like a full uncap in the modern economy. High earners, he said, can work less or report less in taxable wages. Durante added that a New York City business owner could face a stacked top rate around 60 percent, above the roughly 52 percent revenue-maximizing rate estimated by Treasury and Joint Committee on Taxation economists.

The taxed group is small. The share of wages under the cap has slipped from 90 percent in 1982 to about 83 percent now, while the share of workers above the cap has stayed around 7 percent. Bond has put the annual figure near 6 percent and said only about 20 percent of workers ever clear the line in a career. Either way, the bill lands on a thin slice of pay, which is why it polls well and why the growth models show a sharp response.

Medicare and the Debt Wait in the Same Line

Hospital Insurance, Medicare Part A, is on a parallel clock. The same 2026 trustees’ summary says that fund can pay full scheduled amounts until the second quarter of 2033, then 89 percent of Part A costs. Closing that gap would take a cut in scheduled benefits of 12 percent starting in 2026, or a rise in the Medicare payroll tax from 2.90 percent to 3.46 percent.

Medicare’s 2.9 percent tax already applies to all wages, with an extra 0.9 percent above $200,000 for single filers and $250,000 for joint filers. Uncapping Social Security would not refill the HI fund. It would stack another 12.4 points onto the same high wages that already face federal income tax, the uncapped Medicare tax, and, in some states, a steep state income tax.

Jessica Riedl, an economic studies fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, has said a California taxpayer at the top could see a combined marginal rate of 63 percent, counting income, payroll, and state tax. “There’d be no room to tax the rich for anything else,” she said. Andrew Biggs, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, put the same point in fiscal-queue terms: a big payroll-tax increase would leave the government tapped out for later hikes, so Medicare, Medicaid, and the rest of the debt would fall on middle- and lower-income households.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • Two clocks: OASI can fail in late 2032; Medicare HI can fail two quarters later, in the second quarter of 2033.
  • One stacked rate: A full Social Security uncap is a 12.4-point levy on wages that already face federal income tax and uncapped Medicare payroll tax.
  • The debt: The Joint Economic Committee says total gross national debt is $40.10 trillion as of September 3, 2026.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • A bill text: Moreno and Warren have announced a plan, not a scored Senate draft with effective dates and benefit rules.
  • House votes: Cole and Smucker have said they would consider a payroll-tax increase; neither has committed to a full uncap.
  • How the leftover third is closed: No package yet pairs an uncap with a rate change, a retirement-age change, or a benefit formula change that restores 75-year balance.

Critics of a revenue-only fix still argue the program’s problem is spending, including waste, not the size of the wage base. Congress has had years of trustee warnings and has not moved. The new GOP names on a cap-lift do not, by themselves, settle who pays for Part A or for interest on $40.10 trillion.

Extra Tax Would Not Buy Extra Checks

The cap is also the ceiling on the earnings that count toward a Social Security check. For workers at the taxable maximum, the program replaces about 26 percent of earnings, against 74 percent for the lowest earners, according to the trustees’ replacement-rate table. That gap is how the system stays progressive while still tying taxes to benefits.

Moreno and Warren wrote that their plan would help safeguard that earned-benefit structure. Durante’s reply is that an uncap with no extra credit does the opposite. Workers would pay 12.4 percent on wages that never enter the benefit formula.

Social Security would look less like the social insurance program it was designed to be and more like a conventional welfare program.

Alex Durante, senior economist, Tax Foundation, June 24, 2026

Riedl made the same point: if the extra tax does not raise monthly checks, the link between contributions and benefits breaks. Durante’s alternative is to tax employer-sponsored health insurance, which the foundation says would raise $1.8 trillion over 10 years and cut GDP by 0.2 percent, a smaller growth hit than a full uncap.

That is the choice sitting under the new bipartisan language. Tax the wages above $184,500 and keep the extra out of the benefit formula, and you close 67 percent of the hole while turning those dollars into a transfer. Credit the extra wages, and you close 48 percent and still need another source. Leave the cap and raise the 6.2 percent rate instead, and the levy hits every covered worker, including the nurse in the senators’ example.

The remaining third of the 75-year deficit does not disappear because a Republican signed onto a Democratic tax. Medicare’s hospital fund is due a quarter after the retirement fund. The Treasury is already servicing more than $40 trillion. A 12.4-point uncap can buy time for one trust fund. It cannot, on the numbers now on the table, refill all three.

Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of proposed changes to Social Security payroll taxes and is for information only. It is not tax, investment, legal, or retirement-planning advice, and it does not tell any reader to support or oppose a change in the taxable maximum. Consult a qualified tax professional, financial planner, or Social Security benefits counselor before changing how you earn, withhold, or claim benefits. Dollar figures, depletion dates, and bill status come from the public trustee reports, agency tables, and statements cited here and can change with a new report or a new draft.

Harry is the editor and lead writer of THE KISSING PUNK, an independent publication he owns and runs. His ten years in journalism, from reporter to editor, were spent learning to tell an announcement from a rumour, and that distinction runs through the site. A film, an album or a game in the entertainment and gaming pages is reported as confirmed only when the studio, label or publisher has said so on the record, box office and chart figures come from the tracking body that publishes them, and a sports result or transfer is taken from the league or club rather than a fan account. The same separation of the confirmed from the claimed applies in news, business, technology and science, and in lifestyle, travel and auto, where a product's performance is stated only after Harry has tested it. Every number is checked before publication. Where the site gets something wrong, it is corrected under a public corrections policy, and the article shows what was changed. Readers around the world can write to Harry, who reads the mail himself rather than filtering it, at support@thekissingpunk.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending